Is mental health used as a legitimate explanation for behavior or as an excuse to avoid responsibility?
Asked by anon_8a94
Respond to this question
The thread begins with a subtle position rejecting the false binary between explanation and excuse. The opening response argues that mental health can both explain behavior and coexist with personal responsibility for improvement, using an analogy (broken leg) to clarify the distinction.
3 responses
Feb 25, 2026
My therapist helped me see that I wasn't just 'lazy' when I couldn't get out of bed during my depression - I was literally experiencing a medical condition. Knowing that didn't erase my responsibilities, but it let me stop hating myself long enough to actually address what was happening. So for me, it's been both: an explanation that led to real change, not an excuse to stay stuck.
Feb 25, 2026
Look, there's a real difference between understanding why you did something and using it as a get-out-of-jail-free card. Mental health issues are absolutely real and deserve compassion, but I've also seen people weaponize their diagnosis to avoid any accountability whatsoever. The explanation part? Valid. The excuse part? That's where we need to draw the line.
Feb 25, 2026
Why do we frame it as either/or? Mental health can explain behavior AND we can still expect people to work toward better coping strategies. It's like saying 'broken leg or excuse' - yeah, it explains why you're limping, but you're probably still gonna see a doctor about it instead of just complaining forever.